Soy Myths vs Facts: Is Soy Healthy or Not?
Touted as a superhero and denounced as a villain, soy remains at the center of ongoing controversy. Although soybeans may have been grown in China as early as 9,000 B.C. and soy foods are a staple of diets throughout Asian countries, many people are still uncertain whether this plant-based protein has benefits or is a threat to long-term health.
The confusion has given rise to numerous conflicting reports about how soy affects the body, including whether it promotes or reduces the risk of chronic diseases. Finding the whole story requires taking a step back for an objective look at this much-debated bean.
Nutritional Profile of Soybeans
Soy began to make its way into the American diet in the 1960s, but it wasn’t until the 1990s that studies showing potential benefits for heart health led the FDA to approve a claim on soy products stating 25 grams of soy protein per day could reduce the risk of coronary heart disease.
Repeated claims that soy affects thyroid function or has a “feminizing” effect on men are largely unfounded.
Decades of research from the 1970s to the present have shown additional associations between soy consumption and improved health, including:
- A 4% to 6% reduction in LDL cholesterol, which could lower the risk of cardiovascular events by 4% to 12%
- Decreased risk of breast, prostate, and endometrial cancer
- Reduction of menopause symptoms
- Improved ratio of “good” to “bad” bacteria in the gut
- Better bone density and turnover
Although benefits for breast cancer risk and bone health remain subjects of debate, there’s no question that soy boasts a robust nutritional profile. Soybeans and unprocessed soy foods are good sources of protein, fiber, thiamine, riboflavin, folate, vitamin K, copper, manganese, iron, magnesium, and mono- and poly-unsaturated fats. Soy also provides high levels of molybdenum, which plays a key role in antioxidant activity and sulfur metabolism.
Antioxidant and Estrogenic Activity
Soy contains compounds called isoflavones, which can act as antioxidants in the human body. Antioxidant activity may be responsible for the apparent correlation between soy consumption and lower lipid peroxidation, which can reduce the risk of arterial plaques. Higher antioxidant consumption is also associated with decreased cancer risk.
The three major isoflavones in soy—genistin, daidzin, and glycitin—also have weak estrogenic effects. Known as phytoestrogens, these compounds produce pro- or anti-estrogenic effects by binding to estrogen receptors in the body. Whereas human estrogens bind to both estrogen receptor alpha (ERα) and estrogen receptor beta (ERβ), phytoestrogens prefer ERβ, which accounts for the variations in how they affect different tissues. For this reason, phytoestrogens are referred to as selective estrogen receptor modulators, or SERMs.
In addition to interacting with ERβ, phytoestrogens can inhibit the synthesis and activity of enzymes used in estrogen metabolism, altering the way estrogens and androgens behave in the body. Consumption of soy isoflavones can also prevent the activity of tyrosine kinases, enzymes normally responsible for processes such as cell growth, differentiation, metabolism, and apoptosis. Those enzymes may also promote the proliferative activity of cancer cells.
Does Soy Have a Dark Side?
Repeated claims that soy affects thyroid function or has a “feminizing” effect on men are largely unfounded. Compounds in soy can inhibit the entry of iodine into the thyroid gland and interfere with the absorption of thyroid medications, earning them the classification of “goitrogens.” Although some studies suggest women and people with low iodine intake may be more susceptible to these potential effects than men, the majority appear to show no correlation between soy consumption and altered thyroid function.
The biggest problem with soy is likely the way it’s used in processed foods, not it’s consumption in whole forms. Soy is abundant—the U.S. produced 4.31 billion bushels of soybeans in 2016—and food processors incorporate it into a wide variety of products.
Soy protein isolate, present in many mock meats, is a highly processed form of soy protein made by extracting the fat and many of the carbohydrates from soybeans, leaving a product that’s about 90% protein and lacking the majority of the nutrients giving soy its health benefits. Extracted fat from the production of soy protein isolate and other dry soy products is used to make soybean oil, which appears in numerous processed foods with vegetable oil as a main ingredient.
Overall, the confusion about the health effects of soy appears to stem from studies citing high intake levels and the failure to differentiate between whole soy and processed soy foods. For example, in a review of studies showing that soy may decrease ovarian function, effects were seen when daily consumption exceeded 100 milligrams of soy isoflavones, or about four servings of unprocessed soy foods. The study authors concluded “phytoestrogens at very high levels” may be problematic but moderate soy consumption “as part of a well-balanced diet” likely poses no risks.
However, it should be noted that soy is listed among the top eight allergens in the U.S. Between 0.2 and 0.4% of children have soy allergies, and although most of them grow out of it, reactions can continue into adulthood. Avoid eating soy if you experience any of the following symptoms:
- Skin redness
- Tingling in the mouth
- Swelling of the lips, tongue, throat, or face
- Digestive upset
You’re more likely to have a soy allergy if someone else in your family is allergic, and an allergy test can confirm whether soy consumption is responsible for your symptoms.
Some Guidelines for Soy Consumption
Following the basic principles of whole food, plant-based eating is the best way to choose which soy foods to include in your diet. Look for:
- Whole soy — edamame (shelled or in pods), soybeans (canned or dry), soy nuts (dry-roasted soybeans)
- Fermented soy — tempeh, miso, natto
- Soy milk — brands containing only soybeans and water
- Soy flour — made from ground whole soybeans and not defatted
These options contain all or the majority of nutrients believed to give soy its benefits. Dry soybeans can be cooked and used in recipes like other beans and legumes, and tempeh is a delicious alternative to meat in recipes calling for ground beef, sausage, chicken, or bacon. Avoid isolated soy protein and other highly processed soy foods, as well as foods containing soybean oil.
How much soy should you eat? According to Dr. Michael Greger, it’s safe to consume up to five servings per day. Eating more than this could elevate levels of IGF-1 protein in the body and negate some of the positive health effects, such as reduction in cancer risk. One serving is equal to approximately half a cup of tofu, tempeh, or whole soybeans. By following these guidelines, you can include soy as part of a nutritious, whole food, plant-based diet and lifestyle.
- Groves, Melissa. “Is Soy Good or Bad for Your Health?” Healthline. November 22, 2018. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/soy-good-or-bad
- Howard, Jacqueline. “Where Do We Stand on Soy?” CNN. March 29, 2018. https://www.cnn.com/2017/03/07/health/soy-foods-history-cancer-where-do-we-stand-explainer/index.html
- Webster, Allison. “Sound Science: History of Soy and Health.” IFIC Foundation. February 20, 2019.
- Huang, Haiqiu, Hari B. Krishnan, Quynhchi Pham, Liangli Lucy Yu, and Thomas T. Y. Wang. “Soy and Gut Microbiota: Interaction and Implication for Human Health.” Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 64, no. 46 (11, 2016): 8695-709. doi:10.1021/acs.jafc.6b03725.
- Soybeans. http://www.whfoods.com/genpage.php?tname=foodspice&dbid=79
- Molybdenum. http://www.whfoods.com/genpage.php?tname=nutrient&dbid=128
- “Soy Isoflavones and Estrogen.” The Vegan RD. August 04, 2011. https://www.theveganrd.com/2011/08/soy-isoflavones-and-estrogen/
- “Soy Isoflavones.” Linus Pauling Institute. January 02, 2019. https://lpi.oregonstate.edu/mic/dietary-factors/phytochemicals/soy-isoflavones#estrogenic-anti-estrogenic-activities
- Paul, Manash K., and Anup K. Mukhopadhyay. “Tyrosine Kinase – Role and Significance in Cancer.” International Journal of Medical Sciences, 2004, 101-15. doi:10.7150/ijms.1.101.
- Shomon, Mary. “Can You Eat Soy If You Have a Thyroid Condition?” Verywell Health. June 24, 2019. https://www.verywellhealth.com/soy-and-the-thyroid-3231800
- Tonstad, Serena, Karen Jaceldo-Siegl, Mark Messina, Ella Haddad, and Gary E. Fraser. “The Association between Soya Consumption and Serum Thyroid-stimulating Hormone Concentrations in the Adventist Health Study-2.” Public Health Nutrition 19, no. 8 (10, 2015): 1464-470. doi:10.1017/s1368980015002943.
- Messina, Mark, and Geoffrey Redmond. “Effects of Soy Protein and Soybean Isoflavones on Thyroid Function in Healthy Adults and Hypothyroid Patients: A Review of the Relevant Literature.” Thyroid 16, no. 3 (03 2006): 249-58. doi:10.1089/thy.2006.16.249.
- “Soy Is Set to Become Our Biggest Crop by Acreage. But What Are We Doing With This Soy?” Modern Farmer. October 18, 2018. https://modernfarmer.com/2017/12/soy-set-become-biggest-crop-acreage-soy
- Jefferson, Wendy N. “Adult Ovarian Function Can Be Affected by High Levels of Soy.” The Journal of Nutrition 140, no. 12 (10, 2010). doi:10.3945/jn.110.123802.
- “Soy Allergies.” Soyfoods Association | Health Benefits of Making Soy the Preferred Plant Based Protein. http://www.soyfoods.org/nutrition-health/soy-allergies
- “Soy Allergy.” Food Allergy Research & Education. https://www.foodallergy.org/common-allergens/soy-allergy.
- “Soy Allergy.” Mayo Clinic. April 11, 2018. https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/soy-allergy/symptoms-causes/syc-20377802
- Greger, Michael. “How Much Soy Is Too Much?” NutritionFacts.org. October 05, 2012. https://nutritionfacts.org/video/how-much-soy-is-too-much/
- Greger, Michael. “Too Much Soy May Neutralize Benefits.” NutritionFacts.org. October 04, 2012. https://nutritionfacts.org/video/too-much-soy-may-neutralize-plant-based-benefits/
Copyright 2021 Center for Nutrition Studies. All rights reserved.